How to reduce fleet TCO & boost long-term ROI

Total cost of ownership (TCO) is the total cost of acquiring, operating and maintaining a fleet vehicle over its lifecycle, minus its resale value. It includes expenses such as acquisition, depreciation, fuel, maintenance, labor, insurance, taxes and downtime—not just the initial purchase price.

But the value of TCO isn’t simply knowing what your fleet costs. It’s understanding where those costs are coming from, what’s driving them and where there may be opportunities to improve.

Understand what goes into TCO

At its simplest: Acquisition costs + operating costs − resale value = TCO

Some fleet costs are relatively predictable, such as depreciation, taxes and financing. Others can change considerably depending on how vehicles are operated, including fuel, maintenance and labor.

Looking at these costs together provides a more accurate picture of what it takes to keep a vehicle on the road—and makes it easier to see which expenses deserve a closer look.

What contributes to TCO? 

Want to build a custom financial model for your fleet? 

Learn how to calculate Your Fleet ROI and TCO Baseline →

Look for the costs behind the total

A fleet-wide TCO number can tell you how much you’re spending. It doesn’t necessarily tell you why.

That’s where comparison and better fleet data becomes useful. Looking at TCO across similar vehicles, routes, or locations can help identify outliers that deserve a closer look.

Fleet management software can help bring greater visibility to these costs by capturing data such as mileage, fuel use, idling, and vehicle utilization. Looking at that data alongside TCO can help fleet managers identify where costs may be increasing and where to investigate further.

Where should you look first?

Once you have a baseline, look for patterns that could signal unnecessary cost:

• Fuel: Are idling or driver behavior increasing fuel use?  
• Labor: Are overtime or travel time consistently higher in certain teams or routes?  
• Utilization: Are some vehicles carrying ownership costs without enough productive use?  
• Maintenance: Are certain vehicles experiencing repeated repairs or downtime?  
• Risk: Are driver behaviors, accidents or claims increasing financial exposure?  

Labor costs can rise when paid time is lost to unnecessary overtime, inefficient routing or repetitive administrative work. Fleet data can help managers identify where that time is going—and where changes could translate into fleet management cost savings.

Get a clearer view of overtime

GPS fleet tracking can show job-site arrival and departure times, helping managers verify hours, improve payroll and billing accuracy, and identify patterns of avoidable overtime.

Make paid time more productive

Fleet route optimization can help reduce unnecessary travel time between jobs, allowing teams to complete more productive work within the same paid hours.

For more on how routing can improve fuel efficiency, explore Verizon’s Fleet Fuel Cost Guide.

Cut time spent on administration

Automating recurring reports and digital records can reduce repetitive administrative work and make frequently used fleet information easier to access. 

Fleet managers can’t control fuel prices, but they can influence fuel consumption. Telematics can help identify unnecessary mileage, excessive idling and fuel slippage—giving fleets clearer opportunities to reduce fuel costs.

Reduce unnecessary mileage

GPS fleet tracking and route planning can help reduce unnecessary travel. Eliminating just five unnecessary miles per day across a 20-vehicle fleet can prevent more than 25,000 wasted miles per year.

Cut unnecessary engine idling

Tracking engine idling can help fleets distinguish necessary power take-off (PTO) use from non-productive idling, which can burn ¼ to ½ gallon of fuel per hour.

Identify fuel slippage

Matching telematics location data with fuel card purchases can help identify unauthorized fuel transactions and fuel slippage, while also helping automate multi-jurisdiction IFTA reporting.

An underused vehicle can still carry many of the same costs as one that’s on the road every day—from depreciation and insurance to taxes and maintenance. That makes asset utilization an important part of controlling fleet costs.

The opportunity isn’t simply to find vehicles that aren’t moving enough. It’s to understand why they’re underused and whether the business still gets enough value from keeping them. That can lead to better fleet rightsizing decisions about which vehicles to keep, redeploy or remove.

Look beyond the asset utilization number

A vehicle that’s used less than others may be costing the fleet unnecessarily—but low utilization alone doesn’t tell the whole story.

A vehicle may be underused because demand has changed. It may be assigned to a location that no longer needs as much capacity. Or it may serve an important purpose that makes lower utilization reasonable.

Comparing utilization across similar vehicles, teams and locations can help fleet managers identify the outliers. The next step is understanding what’s behind them before deciding whether to act.

When low asset utilization deserves a closer look

Ask:

• Is the vehicle consistently underused, or is demand seasonal?
• Is utilization significantly lower than similar vehicles?
• Could another team or location make better use of it?
• Are you renting capacity elsewhere that this vehicle could provide?
• What does the vehicle continue to cost when it isn’t being used?

Right-size around what the operation actually needs

Once you know which vehicles are underused, the question becomes what to do with them.

Removing every low-utilization vehicle could leave the fleet without enough capacity when demand changes. Keeping every vehicle “just in case,” however, can mean continuing to absorb ownership costs for capacity the business rarely needs.

Fleet rightsizing is about finding the balance. Looking at utilization alongside operational need and total cost of ownership can help managers decide whether an underused vehicle should stay where it is, be redeployed or leave the fleet.

That makes rightsizing less about simply shrinking the fleet and more about matching fleet capacity to actual demand.

Repair or replace?

Asset utilization is only part of the decision. A vehicle may still be heavily used but becoming increasingly expensive to maintain. Looking at maintenance history, downtime and TCO alongside utilization can help fleet managers decide whether continued repairs still make financial sense—or whether replacement deserves consideration.

Decide when to own and when to rent

Not every increase in demand requires another permanent vehicle.

Historical utilization data can help fleet managers distinguish between capacity the business needs consistently and capacity needed only during seasonal or temporary peaks. That can inform decisions about whether it makes more financial sense to own additional vehicles or rent when extra capacity is required.

The aim is to avoid taking on long-term ownership costs for capacity the business only needs part of the time.

Proactive maintenance can help reduce fleet costs by addressing service needs before they become more expensive repairs or unexpected breakdowns. Mileage, engine-hour and diagnostic data can help fleets schedule service at the right time and reduce unplanned downtime.

Get ahead of costly repairs

Engine diagnostics, service records and maintenance reminders can help teams identify service needs earlier—shifting maintenance from something the fleet reacts to into something it can plan for. Companies using fleet management technology reported an average 15% decrease in maintenance costs.

Consider the cost of downtime

An unexpected breakdown costs more than the repair itself. It can also take a vehicle out of service and disrupt scheduled work. Planned maintenance gives fleets more control over when that downtime occurs.

Protect long-term vehicle value

Consistent proactive maintenance can help extend vehicle life, while maintenance records provide a history of how a vehicle has been cared for—useful when it’s time to sell or trade it in.

Risky driving can lead to accidents, claims, higher insurance costs and legal liability. Fleet management software, safety scores and video can help fleets reduce risky behavior while creating a record of how risk is being managed.

Reduce risky driving

GPS fleet tracking can help identify behaviors such as speeding, hard braking and fast acceleration, while AI-powered dashcams can provide added context and support driver coaching. Companies using fleet management technology reported an average 19% decrease in accident costs.

Build a record of fleet safety

Safety scores can help fleets track driver behavior and demonstrate improvement over time. That documented safety record can also be useful in conversations with insurers, who may offer discounts for telematics use or verified safe driving.

When a claim happens, evidence matters

AI-powered dashcams can provide video context when an incident occurs, helping establish what happened and dispute false claims. B.A.M. Trucking deflected a false claim and saved $200,000 on insurance premiums.

Once you know where costs are coming from, the next step is measuring what improvements could be worth.

Fleet management ROI compares the financial value created by improvements with the cost of the technology or changes used to achieve them. Depending on where your fleet has the greatest opportunity, that could include savings in fuel, labor, maintenance and accident costs or gains from improved asset utilization.

Ready to turn fleet data into measurable ROI?

Learn how to establish baseline KPIs, optimize key cost centers and build a sustainable strategy for improving fleet ROI.

Download the eBook: Maximize Fleet ROI with Integrated Solutions →

Calculate your potential fleet savings

See how much your business could save across fuel, maintenance, labor and accident reduction based on your fleet size and operating parameters.

Try the Verizon Connect Fleet Savings Calculator →